4 String vs 5 String Bass: Which One Should You Play?
A 4 string bass is tuned E, A, D, G and covers most songs. A 5 string adds a low B, so it reaches five notes lower and lets you play more notes in one hand position, at the cost of a wider neck and one more string to mute. Beginners usually do best on a 4 string. A 5 string makes sense for styles that use notes below E.
Whether to play a 4 string or a 5 string bass is one of the most common gear questions for bass players. The short answer from my guide to the best bass guitar for beginners is to start on 4. The longer answer depends on what music you play and what your hands like. Here is what really changes when you add a string.
Free: Slap Bass Starter Pack
5 video lessons with slow-motion takes, drum loops and tabs. Enter your email and download it right away.
What Is the Difference Between a 4 and 5 String Bass?
| 4 string | 5 string | |
|---|---|---|
| Standard tuning | E, A, D, G | B, E, A, D, G |
| Lowest note | E, about 41 Hz | B, about 31 Hz |
| Neck width | Narrower | Wider at the nut and the body end |
| String spacing | Usually wider | Often a little tighter |
| Muting | Four strings to control | Five strings, more muting work |
| Weight | Usually lighter | Usually a little heavier |
| Choice of models | Widest | Wide, but fewer budget options |
The four higher strings of a 5 string are tuned exactly like a 4 string bass. Everything you learn on one works on the other. The extra string is an addition, not a different system.
Why Would You Want a Low B String?
The obvious reason is range: five more notes below E, down to B. Many modern recordings, especially in pop, gospel, worship and metal, use notes below E, and on a 4 string you would have to retune to reach them.
The less obvious reason is position. With a B string you can play low notes higher up the neck, without moving your hand to the first frets. Compare this short line on both instruments. It is the same five notes, E, G, A, B and C.
On a 4 string: across the first frets.
G |-------------------
D |-------------------
A |-----------2--3----
E |--0--3--5----------
On a 5 string: the same pitches in one position at the 5th to 8th frets, using the B string.
G |-------------------
D |-------------------
A |-------------------
E |--------5--7--8----
B |--5--8-------------
On the 5 string your hand stays in one place and the notes can sound a little rounder, because they are played away from the nut. Many session players use this.
What Are the Downsides of a 5 String Bass?
- A wider neck. Players with small hands notice it most in the first weeks, especially when reaching around to the B string.
- Tighter string spacing on many models, which takes some getting used to for slap and for fast fingerstyle.
- More muting. An open B string that rings by accident is loud and muddy. You need both hands to keep unused strings quiet.
- A weaker B string on some basses. A low B needs enough tension to sound tight. Some basses use a longer 35-inch scale for that reason, while on others the B sounds a little looser than the other strings.
- A little more weight and, at the same quality, often a higher price.
Should a Beginner Start on a 4 or 5 String Bass?
For most beginners, 4. The narrower neck is easier for a hand that is still learning to stretch, there is less to mute, and the great majority of the songs and lessons you start with were written for 4 strings. It is also easier to find a good, cheap 4 string.
There are exceptions. If you are joining a worship band, a gospel group or a metal band that tunes low, a 5 string from the start saves you from buying twice. Moving from 4 to 5 later is easy, because the four strings you know are still in the same place.
Which Styles Use a 5 String Bass?
| Style | 4 or 5? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Rock, punk, classic funk | 4 is common | Most of the music sits above low E |
| Motown, soul, blues | 4 is common | Traditional sound and range |
| Gospel, worship, modern R&B | 5 is very common | Low notes, keys with many flats, lots of key changes |
| Modern pop and session work | 5 is common | Synth bass parts go below E |
| Metal and down-tuned rock | 5 or a 4 tuned down | Drop and low tunings |
| Jazz | Both | Depends on the player |
Can You Slap on a 5 String Bass?
Yes, many slap players use 5 strings. The main changes are a slightly different thumb angle, because the B string sits under your thumb when you slap the E, and more muting with the side of the thumb. Tighter string spacing on some models can make popping feel cramped. If slap is your main style, try the bass before buying and check the spacing. My slap bass exercises work the same way on both.
What About 6 String Basses?
A 6 string usually adds a high C to the 5 string: B, E, A, D, G, C. It is mostly used for chords, melody and solo playing, in jazz and fusion. The neck is much wider, and it is a specialist instrument rather than a next step for most players. I reviewed a 6 string in my Ken Smith BSR Elite 6 string review.
Which 5 String Basses Have I Reviewed?
If you are leaning toward a 5 string, these reviews cover a range of styles and prices:
- Yamaha TRBX505 active 5 string
- Yamaha BB735A 5 string
- Warwick Corvette Ash 5 string
- FGN Mighty Jazz 5 string
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a 5 string bass harder to play than a 4 string?
A little at first. The neck is wider, the strings are often a little closer together and you have one more string to keep quiet. Most players get used to it with regular playing.
Should a beginner start on a 4 or 5 string bass?
Start on a 4 string unless you already know you need the low notes, for example for a worship band or modern metal. Most songs you will learn first were written on 4 strings, and the narrower neck is easier in the first months.
How is a 5 string bass tuned?
Usually B, E, A, D, G from the thickest string. That is a 4 string bass with an extra low B string. Some 5 strings use a high C instead: E, A, D, G, C.
Can you play 4 string songs on a 5 string bass?
Yes. The four higher strings are tuned exactly like a 4 string bass, so every 4 string bass line and tab works without changes. You simply leave the B string alone, and keep it muted.
What styles use a 5 string bass?
It is common in gospel, worship, modern pop, R&B and metal, and in session work where the bassist may need notes below E. Songs that use a low D, drop D parts and lower tunings are easier on a 5 string, because no retuning is needed.
Is a 5 string bass heavier?
Usually a little, because the neck is wider and there is one more tuner. The body wood and design matter more for weight than the number of strings.
New to Bass? Start Here
Start free with my step-by-step guide on how to play bass guitar and the free Slap Bass Starter Pack. After your first few weeks, send me a video of your playing for a $25 review, and I will show you what to fix before bad habits set in. If you would rather learn with a teacher live, book a 60-minute lesson over Zoom.
Free Slap Bass Starter Pack →Video review, $25 →Live lesson, $60 →